Link to education articles       Link to citizenship articles      Link to bioethics articles  Link to family articles  Link to zeitgeist articles   Media marker

 


   Email your comments to our editor
   Link to more information about CounterCulture
   Subscribe to our emailing list and get free updates about CounterCulture
   Links to other sites of interest and email links
   Link to the site directory, find all articles here
   Link to help for site users


"Streetcar", reviewed by HH
Blanche | Stella and Stanley l Judgements l return to menu

Tennessee William's painful reminder of the ways in which we delude ourselves to find meaning in the world or even just to stay sane, is back at the National Theatre. "A Streetcar Named Desire", a lavish production directed by Trevor Nunn, stars the latest Hollywood Big Name to indulge in live performance to a London audience: Glenn Close.

Blanche
Yes, that's Glenn Close who many of us will remember as Cruella deVille or the vengeful mistress in "Fatal Attraction". So she doesn't seem like the obvious choice to play Williams' unstable and vulnerable Blanche duBois. But whilst she cannot match the fragility that some actresses have brought to the role, the casting is not as unlikely as one might think. When she arrives at the (beautifully designed) New Orleans tenement slum where her sister Stella, and husband, Stanley, live, but you sense that her Blanche is strong enough to unsettle Stella and inspire rebellion, were she to go about it in a different way.

Stella and Stanley
The sisterly similarities between Blanche and Stella (Essie Deans) are very apparent in this production. Both clearly have strong sexual appetites and Stella has been fortunate enough to find satisfaction in her husband, Stanley (Iain Glen - not as brutish as one might hope). Stella's and Stanley's marriage may be one of those that trouble outsiders - we partly share Blanche's bafflement that Stella would return to Stanley after he attacks her - but we also know how strong the relationship is. We can only wince at Blanche's arch comments and flirtatious manner with Stanley, knowing that such behaviour only irritates and appears patronising, rather than charming.

However, Blanche's inappropriate behaviour is also, rather unusually, a source of comedy in this production; one also senses that she herself realises how ridiculous she can sometimes seem. Glenn Close's performance reminds us that Blanche does have intelligence, charm and grace, and that she could indeed be a valuable companion for the right person. The more we find out of Blanche's history, her marriage to a man who cannot respond to her physical needs (he was gay) and her search for love, the more we understand and pity her clinging to the idea of herself as a cultured, refined lady.

Judgements
In real life, of course, we rarely find out so much about a person and often make judgements - as the other characters do - based on their external behaviour, without any allowances. One cannot entirely blame Stanley or Blanche's suitor, Mitch, for the way they respond to some of her behaviour, even before they find out about her history. But the tension and resolution when Stanley and Blanche are finally left alone is as shocking as ever.

It is left up to Stella to show the most pity, overcoming her repulsion at the truth of Blanche's history, even if she can no longer help her. Torn between love for husband and baby, and a desire to help Blanche, she is forced to let her sister once more "depend on the kindness of strangers" and be taken away. For once, rather than feeling relief at Blanche's departure and the restoration of 'normality', I was left wondering what would become of Stella and Stanley, and if Blanche hadn't indirectly succeeded in changing Stella's attitude to her husband forever...

Return to top

home | education | citizenship | bioethics | family | zeitgeist l media
close

Design by Design Blues
Development and administration: Rachel Jordan