Link to education articles       Link to citizenship articles      Link to bioethics articles  Link to family articles  Link to zeitgeist articles   Media marker

 


   Email your comments to our editor
   Link to more information about CounterCulture
   Subscribe to our emailing list and get free updates about CounterCulture
   Links to other sites of interest and email links
   Link to the site directory, find all articles here
   Link to help for site users


"Minority Report ", Reviewed by Phill Dolby
Crimes of intent | Free will | Alternative reality | Calvinism | Activism l return to menu

"To Give you a hope and a future"

Futuristic flick Minority Report contains a profound theological message, writes Phill Dolby.

Spellbinding camera work; delightfully dark aesthetics and a racing plot. These are the elements that combine so spectacularly to make Minority Report the most riveting sci-fi thriller since Blade Runner. It is, of course, mandatory viewing. A film that earned an astonishing £3.9m at the US box office in just four days. And I suppose you would expect so too. As a collaborative work of the previously-only-imagined Cruise-Spielberg cinematic dream team, it was bound to rake in the cash - regardless of it's subject matter. Yet it's subject matter is its most noteworthy feature, the reason for its genuine brilliance. Minority Report, amidst all it's seat-gripping narrative, ambitiously delves into a fascinating discussion. It deals with a timeless theological mystery: the will of God. We have, here before us - moviegoers - an apologetic gift. A film that, through metaphor, effectively puts in motion the Christian world view.

Crimes of intent
Pre-Crime - it works' declares a television advertisement at the outset of the picture. And herein we meet our protagonist, John Anderton [Tom Cruise]. Melancholic and brooding, Cruise is a troubled special cop under an Orwellian policed state that is the USA of 2054. And as a part of the up-and-coming 'Pre-Crime' division, he's committed to stopping murders before they happen. Yes, I said before. Standing on his podium not unlike an orchestral conductor, he uses wired cybergloves to control a sophisticated data-retrieval computer system that helps determine the times, locations and perpetrators of future crimes by replaying the violent premonitions of the 'Pre-cogs' [foetal soothsayers who lay in an electronic flotation tank]. So, after downloading the necessary facts from their prophetic visions, Cruise et al are able to fly, fly, fly to the prospective scene and arrest the murderers... before they commit the murders. Crimes of intent rather than action, if you will.

Free will
A bizarre idea? Well it is. Sort of. But the beauty of the 'Pre-crime' system is that it's seemingly infallible. The murder rate has- after all- fallen to zero. However, things are not all as they seem in future land. When Cruise discovers that the 'Pre-Cogs' foresee him committing a murder himself; he suddenly realizes how the unethical his system is. He gets to see from the convict's point of view. It's a violation of his own free will, he thinks. Perhaps he's even been set up? He'd never do a thing like that! So, quite typical of Philip K Dick novels, Cruise is forced to go on the run. The hunter becomes the hunted, as it were. And it is at this delightful point in the narrative that the spiritual symbolism of the movie comes to the fore.

Alternative reality
On receiving inside information from Pre-Crime's inventor - Lois Smith - Cruise learns that there's hope for him yet: the Pre-Cogs' visions aren't always conclusive. That is, they're not always in unanimous agreement, and there's often a 'Minority Report', a different version of future events - like God's plan for mankind - that cancels out the other's inevitability. So, desperate for his salvation, Cruise races back to 'Pre Crime' HQ, under cover, to steal Agatha - the 'Pre-Cog' who might 'remember' his alternative future. Agatha, insipid and convulsing, soon convinces Cruise that he still has 'free will' in the matter, anyway. He does not have to go through with committing murder if he doesn't want to. 'You have a choice,' she shrieks, 'You can walk away, now!' I don't know about you, but Agatha's words here - besides their freaky delivery - seemed strikingly poignant to me. Their truth resonated, reverberated in my mind. Future events, we are told, do not depend on fate, rather on us. We make the choice.

Calvinism
If the faulty 'Pre-Crime' system could be a strain of contemporary Christian doctrine, it would have to be Calvinism. Calvinism - in a nutshell - traditionally places a huge amount of significance on God's sovereign will, it says 'Que sera, sera' - 'whatever will be will be'. Fate. Accept the status quo, God's will is always done. However, such an idea, I'm afraid, is an unhealthy way of seeing the world. It lends itself to not only absolving us humans of responsibility, but also allows us to blame God for things that are not His fault. How about Third World famine? 'Why doesn't God intervene?' How about War? 'Why doesn't He stop it?' The fact of the matter is, God always uses people. As Cruise finds out, the best future for our lives - God's plan - has to involve us, firstly, discovering it for ourselves; and then, secondly, making it happen.

Action
The 'Pre-Crime' of this world will convince non-Christians that their own 'reality' is the only 'reality' there is. 'Death is the end: there's no God'. The 'Pre-Crime' of this world will tell Christians that the ideal job they have in mind is merely a fantasy; 'If God wants it to happen, he'll hand it to you on a plate'. What society needs more than ever, therefore, is a people like Cruise's character John Anderton. A people who will realize there is a 'Minority Report' for their lives; for the lives of their neighbors, for their school, for their city, for their nation. A people who will rise to action and make God's ways their ways, who will work with Him and choose the very best in every situation and truly be Righteous Revolutionaries in a day of growing depravity, selfishness and secularization.

'"For I know the plans I have for you," declares the Lord, "plans to prosper you and not to harm you, to give you a hope and a future." [Jer. 29:11]

You must choose these plans, though, for the only thing that you'll think inevitable after seeing this movie, you realise, is finding popcorn down your shirt.

Tom Cruise in minority report

Return to top

home | education | citizenship | bioethics | family | zeitgeist l media
close

Design by Design Blues
Development and administration: Rachel Jordan